A Resistance Management Program for Mites
Insects, mites, plant pathogens and weeds all can become resistant to
chemicals used to control them over a period of time. Some say that
greenhouses are among the primary sources of resistant pests
because of the intense pesticide application schedule often carried
out in such enclosed environments. Although some studies have
demonstrated that spider mites (as well as some insect species) in
greenhouses are generally more resistant to pesticides than mites on
outdoor crops, there is little evidence that any greenhouse pesticide
resistance moves outside of the greenhouse.
Spider mites are among the pests
well known for their ability to develop
resistance to pesticides used to
control them. This is partly because
of their biology, their wide host
plant range,and the difficulty of
contacting them with pesticides.
Because we cannot change any of
the characteristics about the mites,
we need to think about pesticide resistance management.
The key to managing pesticide resistance is using pesticides wisely.
Wise use includes avoiding unnecessary applications and overuse of
the same kind of chemistry. One of the best ways to do this is with a
pest scouting and monitoring program. Knowing what pests are
there, where they are and some estimate of the infestation level will
help a control program at the beginning and throughout the entire
crop production cycle. When possible, use alternatives to pesticides to
reduce pest numbers. In the case of spider mites, alternatives may
include eliminating weeds that harbor mite infestations, maintaining
greenhouse temperature and humidity within moderate ranges, and
introducing predatory mites.
Advising growers to minimize pesticide use may seem unusual coming
from a chemical company, but it’s in our interest as well as yours to
avoid unnecessary pesticide applications. Our job, as chemical suppliers
and growers, is to apply pesticides in such a responsible way that
resistance development is delayed as long as possible in order to preserve
the effectiveness of pesticides.
Pesticides will be needed for spider mite control in most greenhouses
– especially during hot weather. In addition to minimizing pesticide
use, another principle of pesticide resistance management is to not
depend on one or two kinds of chemistry for control, but to rotate
among at least three (preferably four) different chemical modes of
action. Fortunately, at this time,we have these different choices of
modes of action available to us in most areas of the United States. It’s
a good thing that so many different products are available because
label directions on many of them, especially those registered recently,
have specific instructions on the number of applications permitted.
This is, of course, to minimize exposure to one mode of action.
Finally,a chemical application is only as good as the coverage
obtained. Most of the products need to contact the mites or the leaf
surfaces on which they walk and feed, to be effective. Judo, Pylon and
TetraSan have translaminar activity; i.e.the active ingredient moves
from upper to lower leaf surfaces – and vice-versa - after application.
This helps a bit if coverage is less than perfect, but good coverage will
result in even better control. Below
are two examples of a rotational program
for mite control:
I. Low Initial Infestation
Application |
Miticide |
Chemical Class |
MOA Group |
Residual |
REI |
1 |
Judo™ (2-4 fl oz/100 gal) |
Tetronic acid |
23 |
30 days |
12 |
2 |
Pylon® (2.6 fl oz/100 gal) |
Pyrrole |
13 |
21-28 days |
12 |
3 |
Floramite® (2-4 fl oz/100 gal) |
Carbazate |
25 |
21-28 days |
12 |
4 |
Judo™ (2-4 fl oz/100 gal) |
Tetronic acid |
23 |
30 days |
12 |
5 |
Pylon® (2.6 fl oz/100 gal) |
Pyrrole |
13 |
21-28 days |
12 |
II. High Initial Infestation
Application |
Miticide |
Chemical Class |
MOA Group |
Residual |
REI |
1 |
Triact® (1-2 gal/100 gal) |
Clarified hydrophobic extract of neem oil |
N/A |
3-7 days |
4 |
2 |
Judo™ (2-4 fl oz/100 gal) |
Tetronic acid |
23 |
30 days |
12 |
3 |
Pylon® (2.6 fl oz/100 gal +
TetraSan™ (8-16 fl oz/100 gal) |
Pyrrole +
2,4 Diphenyloxzoline
|
13+
10 |
21-28 days
21-28 days
|
12
12 |
4 |
Floramite® (2-4 fl oz/100 gal) |
Carbazate |
25 |
21-28 days |
12 |
5 |
Judo™ (2-4 fl oz/100 gal) |
Tetronic acid |
23 |
30 days |
12 |
6 |
Pylon® (2.6 fl oz/100 gal +
TetraSan™ (8-16 fl oz/100 gal) |
Pyrrole +
2,4 Diphenyloxzoline |
13+
10 |
21-28 days
21-28 days
|
12
12 |
*Floramite is a registered trademark of Crompton/Crop Protection Division of Chemtura Corporation. Judo is a trademark of OHP, Inc. Pylon is a registered trademark of BASF Corporation. TetraSan is a trademark
of Valent USA Corporation. Triact is a registered trademark of Certis USA. |